Single-Member Electoral Districts Cannot Be Unconstitutional Because They Form Part of the Constitution of Canada


Introduction 

The Ontario Court of Appeal issued a ruling in August 2025 which upheld the constitutionality of single-member electoral districts and lambasted so-called “Fair Vote British Columbia” (which for some reason litigated single-member plurality in Ontario) for having “repackage[ed] failed political arguments as constitutional rights violations.”[1] Justice Huscroft declared unambiguously: “The electoral system is not in conflict with either the right to vote or the right to equality. It does not violate the Charter.”[2]

Continue reading

Posted in Amending Formulas, Constitution (Written), Electoral Boundaries Readjustments, Electoral Reform | Leave a comment

His Majesty King Charles III of Canada Visits Ottawa, 2025


From a vantage point on Parliament Hill, I took these photos of His Majesty King Charles III of Canada while he and the Queen consort greeted dignitaries at the national cenotaph.

Continue reading

Posted in Crown (Powers and Office) | 1 Comment

Mark Carney First Asked His Majesty the King to Deliver the Next Speech from the Throne Back in March, Says George Osbourne


George Osborne, Chancellor of the Exchequer from 2010 to 2016, revealed on his podcast Political Currency on 29 May 2025 that Mark Carney had first asked His Majesty the King to open the 45th Parliament as King of Canada back on 17 March 2025. Osborne claimed that Carney had told him about all this directly during the same visit to London in mid-March 2025, shortly after his appointment as prime minister but before the dissolution of parliament for a general election. Osborne said in full:

Continue reading

Posted in Caretaker Convention & Government Formation, Constitutional Conventions, Crown (Powers and Office), Prime Minister's Powers | Leave a comment

Review of The Crisis of Canadian Democracy by Andrew Coyne


In The Crisis of Canadian Democracy, Andrew Coyne repeats the same refrain that has made the rounds for decades but presents his polemic as if it were original. His superficial assertions seem like profound arguments at first glance, and an inescapable implication weaves throughout his narrative: if only everyone thought as Andrew Coyne does, then so many of our problems would solve themselves. I risk giving Coyne too much attention and legitimacy by reviewing this book at all, but the bulk of this book merits a thorough refutation because he seems to have garnered such a following, especially from the credulous at The Hub, The Agenda with Steve Paikin, and the Monk Centre.

Continue reading

Posted in Articles and Books, Reviews | 1 Comment

Updates on the Reform Act and Fixed-Date Elections


Nova Scotia Shows a Better Way

In February, I outlined a government bill tabled by Tim Houston, Premier of Nova Scotia, which contained a line to repeal the province’s fixed-date elections law, amongst other things. The omnibus Government Organization and Administration Act received Royal Assent on 26 March 2025, and thus makes Nova Scotia both the last province to have adopted a fixed-date elections law and the first province to have repealed it outright.

Continue reading

Posted in Electing & Ousting Party Leaders, Fixed-Date Elections, Party Discipline | Leave a comment